The Big Questions - What Brake Pad Compound should I be Using?

11 July 2013  |   |   3 Comments

When it comes to choosing brake pads it would be fair to say it's just one of the many minefields when it comes to getting the right components on your bike to match the type of riding you undertake...

You log online to a retailer and find the right size for your brake caliper of choice and then are faced with a decision… What compound do I really need? Organic, Sintered or even Kevlar? Why is one better than the other and will I still be able to stop if I’m on the wrong compound?

brake pads

I have vivid memories of spending an evening trying to get to the bottom of this problem a few years back and all I could ever find was a whole lot of contradictory information on forums so I shall attempt to brake the trend,  and bring the confusion to a skidding halt. (Insert more terrible brake pad puns...)

At this point, most people take the 50/50 gamble and opt for the cheapest option Which is pretty much what I would do anyway! Once bedded in your new brake pads will probably stop you better than the tired old ones you’ve just removed but they might not last as long as you had hoped or just not generate the desired power and bite in certain conditions. This is why we have different compounds of pads!

There are 2 main types of pad out there that you can get from a large range of manufactures to suit nearly all brakes. They are called sintered and organic it’s also possible to get a Kevlar compound which sits somewhere in between the 2.

NB. Using 3rd party brands of brake pads on some manufactures systems can void your warranty so make sure you always take time to read that giant sheet of folded paper that comes with all new bike products in 15 languages that we all just throw back in the box. Unbelievably it may come in use one day…

Sintered Pads

Sintered pads consist of hardened metal ingredients bound together at high temperatures under pressure onto a metal backing that fits inside your brake caliper. It’s very hard to quantify the actual power you will get from as it’s variable on the composition of specific pads but on the whole they will experience brake fade at higher temperatures than organic pads making them the perfect choice for your trip to the alps this summer. They will also be a much better bet in the wet and mud than an organic pad cutting through the slop as opposed to absorbing. They may not have the most bite but as a fit and forget solution sintered pads are the way to go.

Organic Pads

Organic pads are constructed from fibers and organic material bonded together with resin. Typically they won’t last as long as a sintered compound but they will get a bit more bite in dry. Organic pads aren’t really suitable for the wet as the fiber in the pad will take on water and mud eventually hydroplaning on the surface of the rotor. They also don’t cope with heat in the same ways as a sintered pad as the organic fibre insulates the caliper and pushes more heat into the actual disk making them a little more susceptible to fading. Not ideal if you ride in all conditions and don’t have the time to think about changing your pads but you would get a little more bite when used in favorable conditions.

Kevlar Pads

Kevlar compounds like you can get from Superstar sit somewhere in between sintered and organic. In terms of bite, wear and weather performance making them a pretty solid bet for a UK trail rider who is reasonably maintenance conscious.

So now when it comes to choosing your next pair of brake pads it’s less of a stab in the dark and more an educated decision on what’s best the majority of the time.

And always remember It’s rarely ever possible to be on the perfect brake pad at all times but its very possible to be on the wrong compound!

Do you want to read more of this kind of thing on MoreDirt? Tell us what you think in the comments below!

3 Comments

wythall1 said on: 11 July 2013 11:57

Good Article Angus!
Over the past few years I have tried all sorts of pad compound from different pad manufacturers.
My final conclusion, which came about 18 months ago was to use Superstar Organic pads. I use these pads all year round and I have not experienced the fading problems or lack of bite in adverse conditions as mentioned above, but this is probably due to the fact that I run Hayes stroker ace 4 pots and the pads are huge! What I do agree with is the fact that they don't last a huge amount of time. But saying that, at a fiver a pair or £17 for and four pairs from Superstar that is not really an issue when they are a third of the price of the big name pads.

AngusMcIntosh replied on: 11 July 2013 12:36

I think a large part of it is just keeping on top of how much wear you have left in the pads! all the terms and names was just one of those things that had always bugged me that nobody had ever written something like this before (That i could find anyway)! Glad you found it useful!

steve c said on: 12 July 2013 06:55

It is an issue im sure all riders will come across at some time, and in my experience its just a case of trying all options. I have had sintered that have been awesome in most conditions, both from the manufacturer and third parties, cost being a major consideration in the end.. the organics in the summer performing similar but perhaps a little more prone to 'cooking'.... Ceramics are good for DH, but the very slight delay before good bite can be a little errrrr, disturbing... but my personal favourite ? the teflon pad from Superstar, great bite in all conditions, almost uncookable, and definitely worth the little extra (£25.00 x 4 prs), the only issue being wear, and my god they do, but better that than poor brakes... Good article Angus, and good idea.. could open a can of worms if you get into 26er/29er discussions, hardtail/full suss, tyres ect.. but any comparison style article will bring other opinions, not such a bad thing ;-)

Comment on this article

Want to add your comments about this review? Login or Sign-up by clicking the button below..

Login/Sign Up